← Back to dining / Home / Chicago
dining · Long read 08/10

Widely believed, mostly wrong

Four assumptions that survive because nobody checks them.

7 min read14 recordsChicago

Four beliefs that circulate widely and collapse on contact with a spreadsheet.

The most repeated claims about Chicago are the least examined ones, and they survive because repeating them costs nothing.

  • Walk from 175 N State south to 400 S, 20 minutes end to end
  • The Macy's atrium is on the ground floor and free; weekday mornings are quiet
  • Route 62 runs the length of State; skip the taxi
  • The sign photographs best from the east sidewalk, half an hour after sunset

Not everything widely said is wrong, but these four are.

Each item below is widely believed, easy to check, and wrong — or true only under conditions nobody mentions.

  • Board at Clark/Lake and stay on the full circle, 25 minutes back to the start
  • Wabash and Randolph is the best corner for shooting the trestle
  • 17:00–18:00 is the densest service and the most crowded; travel light

The most repeated claims are the least examined ones.

The pattern is consistent: general advice written for a different city, applied here without adjustment.

  • AlineaTasting menu $300–400 a head; wine extraGrant Achatz's laboratory of a restaurant, where a course may hang above the table or be poured onto the cloth. It is closer to a performance than a meal.
  • Maxwell Street Polish at Jim's OriginalPolish $7–9; pork chop sandwich $8A grilled sausage with caramelised onion, mustard and a sport pepper in a long roll. This is what is left of the old Maxwell Street market, and only a few windows still do it.
  • Dim Sum at MingHinBaskets $5–8; $25–35 a headChinatown on Archer is the Chinese center of the Midwest. On a weekend morning the dim sum carts move faster than the customers, and nobody here is performing for tourists.
  • Deep Dish at Lou Malnati's9-inch $26–32 for two; toppings $2–3 eachChicago deep dish is not a thick-crust pizza; it is built upside down, cheese on the bottom, sauce on top. A pie takes 35 to 45 minutes, and there is no hurrying it.

Correct one of these before you arrive and the whole first week gets cheaper.

  • The Loop
  • Lincoln Park
  • Wicker Park